[Verse 1] I saw the seam along your hull Before the harbor let us go Still I climbed aboard your promise Certain hearts could learn to change [Pre-Chorus] You called it fate, I called it hope And let the warning drift below [Chorus] You were an open book in front of me Every page laid bare, every line in view You wore your mystery like a second skin But the truth kept finding its way through Even when you swore by what we treasured most The lie could never hold its shape I saw the hole in your ship on day one Still I sailed, believing love could save [Verse 2] You spoke in riddles, soft and sure As if the dark could hide the ink But every careful word gave you away Before I had the chance to think [Pre-Chorus] You raised that sacred memory Like it could make the story true [Chorus] You were an open book in front of me Every page laid bare, every line in view You wore your mystery like a second skin But the truth kept finding its way through Even when you swore by what we treasured most The lie could never hold its shape I saw the hole in your ship on day one Still I sailed, believing love could save [Bridge] I wanted you to be the exception The one bright answer to the rule But I mistook my own devotion For a power that could reach you [Final Chorus] You were an open book in front of me Every page laid bare, every line in view You wore your mystery like a second skin But the truth kept finding its way through You swore by the memory we held so close Still the truth came easy, clean, and plain I saw the hole in your ship on day one And sailed until I learned to leave [Outro] I saw it from the start I only hoped you’d change